Underdogs · 2 min read ·

Fifth Harmony lost The X Factor to Tate Stevens, then had 8 Hot 100 entries to his none

Fifth Harmony finished third on The X Factor in 2012, then went on to 8 Hot 100 entries. Winner Tate Stevens has none.

Fifth Harmony

Fifth Harmony · August 16, 2013

Photo: orangesporanges · CC BY 2.0 · Photo source.

Fifth Harmony finished third on The X Factor in 2012, then went on to 8 Hot 100 entries. Work from Home reached No. 4. Tate Stevens won the season and a $5 million deal with Syco Music and RCA Records Nashville. By October 2013 he had left the label. He has no Hot 100 entry and no certified single or album since the show.

Gabby Barrett and Chris Daughtry passed their winners by millions

Gabby Barrett finished third on American Idol in 2018. The next year she released I Hope on her own, and a remix with Charlie Puth reached No. 3 on the Hot 100. Her singles carry 15.5 million certified units. Maddie Poppe, who won her season, has none.

Chris Daughtry finished fourth in 2006 and has 12.5 million. Taylor Hicks, the winner, has 500,000.

Certified single units since the show

Six seasons where a finalist who lost has more RIAA-certified single units than the winner.

American Idol season 16, 2018

Gabby BarrettThird place15.5 million
Maddie PoppeWinner0

American Idol season 5, 2006

Chris DaughtryEliminated 4th12.5 million
Taylor HicksWinner500,000

The Voice season 3, 2012

Melanie MartinezEliminated in the Top 66.5 million
Cassadee PopeWinner1 million

The Voice season 8, 2015

Corey Kent WhiteEliminated in the Top 84.5 million
Sawyer FredericksWinner0

American Idol season 14, 2015

JAXEliminated (3rd)2 million
Nick FradianiWinner0

American Idol season 2, 2003

Clay AikenRunner-up1.5 million
Ruben StuddardWinner500,000
Gabby Barrett

Photo: HoityToity13 · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Photo source.

“Little Red Wagon”, Top 3 – Finale
Clip uploaded by Breaking Talents Showcase on YouTube

Daughtry’s albums out-certify Hicks’s eight to one

Daughtry’s albums carry 8 million certified units and Hicks’s 1 million. Clay Aiken, runner-up in 2003, has 3.5 million to Ruben Studdard’s 1.5 million. Melanie Martinez went out in the Top 6 of The Voice in 2012 and has 3 million. Cassadee Pope, who won, has none.

Certified album units since the show

Six seasons where a finalist who lost has more RIAA-certified album units than the winner, largest first.

American Idol season 5, 2006

Chris DaughtryEliminated 4th8 million
Taylor HicksWinner1 million

American Idol season 2, 2003

Clay AikenRunner-up3.5 million
Ruben StuddardWinner1.5 million

The Voice season 3, 2012

Melanie MartinezEliminated in the Top 63 million
Cassadee PopeWinner0

The X Factor season 2, 2012

Fifth HarmonyThird place2 million
Tate StevensWinner0

American Idol season 16, 2018

Gabby BarrettThird place1 million
Maddie PoppeWinner0

American Idol season 8, 2009

Adam LambertRunner-up500,000
Kris AllenWinner0
Chris Daughtry

Photo: Staff Sgt. Shane Ellis · Public domain · Photo source.

“Renegade”, Top 5 – Contestants' birth year & Current Billboard top 10
Clip uploaded by TheUsher82 on YouTube

Seventh-place Jennifer Hudson draws five times Fantasia’s readers

Jennifer Hudson went out seventh on American Idol in 2004. In 2006 she played Effie White in Dreamgirls and won the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress. Over the last 12 months her Wikipedia article drew 1.2 million views, five times as many as Fantasia’s.

Wikipedia readers, October 2025 to September 2026

Views of each singer’s own English Wikipedia article. Six seasons where a finalist who lost has more readers than the winner, most-read first.

American Idol season 3, 2004

Jennifer HudsonEliminated 7th1.2 million
Fantasia BarrinoWinner241,840

The Voice season 6, 2014

Christina GrimmieThird place1.2 million
Josh KaufmanWinner18,288

The Voice season 3, 2012

Melanie MartinezEliminated in the Top 6867,475
Cassadee PopeWinner193,606

American Idol season 5, 2006

Katharine McPheeRunner-up825,781
Taylor HicksWinner246,936

American Idol season 8, 2009

Adam LambertRunner-up748,764
Kris AllenWinner94,141

American Idol season 2, 2003

Clay AikenRunner-up506,688
Ruben StuddardWinner206,535
Jennifer Hudson

Photo: Staff Sergeant Bradley Lail, United States Air Force · Public domain · Photo source.

Read another story

Photo credits (21 photos)